This present was first mentioned in I Moved! / Some Extras (Posted October 17, 2013). In the episode Jenna says when she was a kid (about 8) she wrapped a present. It is labeled "To: God Love: Jenna". Jenna to this day doesn't know what the box contains, though she believes it may be something like a really sweet note. Every Christmas Jenna puts the present under her tree along with all of her other presents. According to Jenna she thinks about opening it every year but tells herself "nah, I'll open it next year."